Limits of British Power
When studying the American Revolution, we tend to focus on our Founding Fathers and the challenges they faced from April 1775 to September 1783. However, on the other side of the Atlantic, the British Parliament, British Army, and Royal Navy faced challenges of their own: the tyranny of distance and limited resources- money, people, facilities, and equipment.
What is often overlooked is the British government’s clear lack of understanding of what it would take to put down the rebellion. Much of their thinking was distorted by their own hubris. After all, 12 years earlier, England soundly defeated the French in the Seven Years’ War, took over most of their North American empire, and now was the undisputed world superpower.
By 1775, Great Britain was clearly the richest and most powerful nation in the world and their leaders never really came to grips with what it would take to end the rebellion. So, let’s start with geography.
During the French and Indian War, most battles were fought in Quebec, Ontario, Nova Scotia, and Newfoundland, along with those in Pennsylvania, Western Virginia, and upstate New York. Looking at a map and excluding Canada, this is only a fraction of the land the 13 Colonies occupied.
Add that the U.S. East Coast is dotted with deep-water harbors. To keep a single frigate on station at each port required a minimum of three, more likely four. Anyone in the Admiralty could do the math, and the Royal Navy simply didn’t have the ships to effectively blockade the East Coast. Instead, they chose a few and left the others alone, which let U.S. privateers and frigates into the Atlantic and Caribbean to prey on British shipping.
At the height of their “power” during the American Revolution, the British Army held New York, Savannah, Charleston, Newport, RI, and Wilmington, NC. In the thinking of the time, if they captured Philadelphia, the Revolution’s capital, the war would be over. The Continental Congress simply moved west for the year (July 1777 to July 1778) the British Army held Philadelphia, and the war continued.
In 1777, the British believed it could split off the more rebellious northern colonies – CT, MA, NY, and RI – from the rest, and the war would end. Burgoyne’s defeat at Saratoga in October 1778 put an end to that strategy and brought France into the war.
Then in 1781, Cornwallis decided he would defeat the Continental Army in the south and destroy North Carolina’s cash crop of tobacco. Instead, Generals Greene and Morgan led Cornwallis on a merry chase that exhausted his supplies, routed Tarleton at Cowpens, and forced Cornwallis to run to Wilmington, NC to be evacuated. From there, he was taken to Hampton, VA, met with Benedict Arnold’s small army, and retreated to Yorktown.
In the 13 Colonies, the British Army had, at its peak, about 50,000 – 55,000 soldiers, about 25,000 of which were German mercenaries. They were divided amongst the garrisons along the coast. There simply weren’t enough troops to hold what they had and defeat the Continental Army.
Each time the British Army ventured forth to take on the Continental Army, first they had to chase it, then fight it on a battlefield that wasn’t often of its choosing. All Washington had to do was give the British Army a bloody nose and withdraw because he knew that he could not win the war in one battle. However, if the Continental Army was decimated and no longer an effective fighting force, the war was, if not over, it would take much longer to win.
Beginning in 1780, General Sir Henry Clinton, Commander of the British forces in the 13 Colonies, kept asking for 30,000 more troops. Parliament refused to provide them. Why? Money.
By 1780, the war was becoming increasingly unpopular. British merchants felt the pain of losses at sea, and they knew that when it was over, they would be taxed to pay for the war.
Who were these British leaders who refused made the decisions that drove the British strategy? Stay tuned, because next week this blog will cover the British leaders who lost America.
January 1777 Richard St. George Mansergh-St. George cartoon about the British Army titled My Triumphant Entry to Philadelphia.